Table of Contents

During my conversation with Catie Payne on the Reskillience podcast, we touched briefly on the topic of swarming and why natural beekeeping takes such a different approach to this phenomenon compared to conventional practices. I’ve been thinking more about this subject since our discussion and wanted to clarify why I believe swarming is not a problem to be prevented but a natural miracle to be respected and worshipped.

The Great Misunderstanding

If you’ve been around beekeeping circles, you’ve probably heard swarm prevention discussed as a fundamental aspect of hive management. New beekeepers are often taught that swarming is something to be avoided at all costs – a failure of management or a loss of valuable bees and honey production.

This perspective misses something profound: swarming is how bee colonies reproduce. It’s as natural and necessary as any other form of reproduction in nature. When we aggressively prevent swarming, we’re essentially sterilizing the colony and denying its most fundamental biological imperative.

I’d like to reframe how we think about swarming and offer a different approach – one that respects this natural process while still being practical for beekeepers.

What Actually Happens During a Swarm

Let’s start by understanding what swarming really is. A honeybee colony is best understood not as a collection of individual bees but as a single superorganism. The colony as a whole is the true organism, with individual bees functioning more like cells within a body.

When a colony swarms, it’s reproducing – the organism is dividing into two. Here’s the process:

  1. As spring approaches and resources become abundant, the colony begins preparing to reproduce
  2. Workers create queen cells to raise new queens
  3. Just before the first new queen emerges, the old queen and about half the workers (often 10,000 bees) leave the hive
  4. This swarm clusters temporarily while scout bees search for a suitable new home
  5. Once decided, the swarm moves to its new location and begins building comb
  6. Back in the original hive, a new queen emerges, often mates, and continues the colony

This is a complete reproduction event – one colony has become two. It’s the equivalent of cell division at the superorganism level.

Why Conventional Beekeeping Fights Swarming

Commercial beekeeping operations generally try to prevent swarming for several reasons:

  1. Reduced honey production: A colony that swarms diverts resources to reproduction rather than surplus honey storage
  2. Lost workforce: Losing half the worker population means fewer foragers collecting nectar
  3. Neighborhood concerns: Swarms in urban or suburban areas can cause anxiety for neighbors
  4. Management preferences: Artificial insemination in queens and multiplication through splits gives beekeepers more control of genetics

These are legitimate concerns for commercial operations focused on maximizing honey yield or pollination services. But for backyard beekeepers who aren’t paying their mortgage with honey production or pollination, there’s another way to approach swarming.

The Natural Beekeeping Perspective

In natural beekeeping, we recognize swarming as essential for several reasons:

1. Genetic Diversity and Adaptation

When a colony swarms, the new queen typically mates with 5-25 different drones from other colonies in the area. This brings fresh genetics into the colony, increasing diversity and resilience. Over time, this natural process allows bees to adapt to local conditions and develop resistance to pests and diseases.

2. Colony Health Reset

Swarming creates a brood break – a period where no new brood is being raised. This interruption in the brood cycle can break the reproductive cycle of parasites like varroa mites, potentially reducing pest pressure naturally.

3. Rejuvenation

A young, newly-mated queen typically has stronger pheromones and better egg-laying capacity than an aging queen. The swarming process ensures regular queen renewal without beekeeper intervention.

4. Natural Selection

Allowing colonies to swarm and establish new wild colonies enables natural selection to operate. Those colonies best adapted to local conditions survive and pass on their genetics, while less adapted colonies may not make it through challenging periods.

A Middle Path: Working With Natural Swarming

Rather than fighting against swarming or letting it happen completely unmanaged, I advocate for a middle approach that respects this natural process while being responsible and practical:

1. Set Up Swarm Traps

Swarm traps (also called bait hives) are small hives or boxes placed strategically around your property. Baited with lemongrass oil (which mimics bee pheromone) and placed at appropriate heights, these traps attract swarms, including those from your own hives.

This allows the natural swarming process to occur while increasing your chances of catching and housing the swarm. The bees get to follow their natural reproductive cycle, and you potentially gain a new colony.

2. Maintain Swarm Awareness

Learn to recognize the signs that a colony is preparing to swarm:

  • Backfilling of the brood nest with honey
  • Queen cup construction along the bottoms of frames
  • Congestion in the brood area
  • Changes in worker behavior (less foraging, more clustering)

This awareness allows you to prepare appropriately and be ready when swarming season arrives.

A Top Bar Hive

3. Practice Split Swarming

If you identify a colony with uncapped queen cells preparing to swarm and have reasons to prevent them from leaving (such as being in a dense urban area), you can perform what is called a “split swarm” – essentially creating an artificial swarm:

  1. Find the queen in the colony that’s preparing to swarm
  2. Move her with several frames or combs of bees, brood and stores into a new hive
  3. Move the original hive to another location only meters away but more than two meters
  4. Place the new hive in the original location
  5. The new hive will attract all the forager bees
  6. The original colony will raise a new queen and continue to thrive in its new location
  7. You’ve effectively replicated the natural swarm process while maintaining control
  8. This approach respects the colony’s natural inclination while preventing unexpected swarms that might cause issues in your neighborhood.

4. Community Education

One of the biggest issues with swarming is the fear it generates in people unfamiliar with bee behavior. Educating neighbors about the gentle nature of swarms (bees in swarm state are typically very docile as they have no home to defend) can reduce anxiety and calls to exterminators.

I’ve found that offering to collect swarms from neighbors’ properties, perhaps with the incentive of a jar of honey, creates goodwill and saves bees. You might even inspire new beekeepers in the process!

I feel strongly that it’s our responsibility as beekeepers to be prepared to catch swarms freely as a service to our community

Designed for Bees.
Loved by Beekeepers.
Experience the simplicity of the Kenyan Top Bar Hive.
Available for delivery anywhere in Australia.
Order your Hive Today

The Beauty of the Swarm

Beyond the practical aspects, there’s something profoundly beautiful about witnessing a swarm. Tens of thousands of bees moving as one organism, making collective decisions through what scientists call “swarm intelligence” – it’s one of nature’s most remarkable phenomena.

When a colony swarms, scout bees search for potential new homes, then return to the cluster to perform dances indicating the direction, distance, and quality of sites they’ve found. Other bees check these locations, and gradually, through this democratic process, the swarm reaches consensus on the best available home.

This decision-making process is so sophisticated that it’s been studied by researchers developing algorithms for everything from traffic management to artificial intelligence. The bees’ ability to collectively process information and reach optimal decisions without central control is something we’re still trying to fully understand and replicate.

A bee swarm hanging from a tree

Catching Your First Swarm

For new beekeepers, catching your first swarm is often a transformative experience. Here are some tips if you’d like to try:

  1. Prepare a suitable home in advance – have a hive ready and in it’s permanent position
  2. Keep basic swarm catching equipment ready during swarm season:
    • A bee suit or at least a bee veil
    • A spray bottle with water (lightly misting helps calm and settle bees)
    • A cardboard box or bucket for collection
    • Packing tape to seal the box
    • Pruning shears (sometimes needed for branch removal)
    • A white sheet to spread under the swarm cluster
  3. Move slowly and deliberately – swarms are typically very gentle
  4. Lay the sheet on the ground below the swarm cluster incase they fall or miss the box/bucket
  5. Hold your collection container below the swarm cluster
  6. With a swift motion, shake or brush the main cluster into your container
  7. Watch for signs that the queen was captured (bees will begin moving toward the container if she’s inside)
  8. Transfer to your prepared hive once you’ve collected the majority of the bees

The feeling of successfully homing a wild swarm connects you to thousands of years of human-bee partnership and provides a strong start for a new colony with natural instincts intact.

Check out this video to see Adrian capturing and re-homing a swarm: 

Final Thoughts

Swarming isn’t a beekeeping failure – it’s the most natural success a colony can achieve. It represents the fulfillment of the colony’s biological purpose and demonstrates its health and vitality.

By shifting our perspective from fighting against swarming to working with this natural process, we create a more harmonious relationship with our bees. We allow them to express their full nature while still meeting our needs as beekeepers.

This approach requires more awareness and flexibility than strict swarm prevention, but it results in stronger, more resilient colonies adapted to local conditions. It also provides the joy of occasionally receiving the gift of a new colony – a dividend of working with natural processes rather than against them.

Whether you’re just starting your beekeeping journey or reconsidering established practices, I encourage you to see swarming through this new lens – not as a problem to solve, but as a miracle to respect and celebrate.

Long Live the Swarm!

Bee in the Buzz

Stay inspired with essential tips, expert advice, and exclusive offers for beekeepers! Whether you’re a beginner or a pro, our newsletter is your go-to resource for thriving hives.

Sign up today and elevate your beekeeping journey!

 

FAQs

Actionable Tips